Wojtek Wiesławski
Tutorials

Stop Recording and Editing Guitars Like This: 3 Editing Mistakes

Why "we'll fix it in editing" doesn't work — tuning, time stretching and copy-paste on guitars.

Chapters

“It doesn’t matter how it’s recorded ⁠—⁠ we’ll edit it and it’ll be great.” In this episode Wojtek Wieslawski takes that myth apart using guitar tracks an engineer received for mixing as “edited and ready”. Three short excerpts, three different problems.

1. The guitar is out of tune

One string in the chord is simply out of tune ⁠—⁠ and that can’t be fixed. The only solution is to tune the guitar and record the part again. It’s the absolute basic: don’t go any further without it.

2. Time stretching and crossfades

In the second example the crossfades are done badly, so you hear double attacks, double hits. On top of that the notes are stretched to extremes, which causes warbling. The goal was to get every single hit perfectly on the grid ⁠—⁠ the result is artifacts. It turned out the guitarist recorded each chord separately, sometimes only once. Wojtek picked the best-feeling passes of the first and second chords and simply joined them, with hardly any processing. It isn’t perfect, but it sounds far more natural. Nobody plays perfectly, and editing doesn’t need to pretend otherwise.

3. Copy-pasting every note

The third riff was recorded note by note and assembled in editing. Two cardinal mistakes: several notes use exactly the same copied pick attack, and there are no natural transitions between notes. The editing was also done on a high-gain tone that masks artifacts ⁠—⁠ then the mix brief says the guitar should be a light crunch, and suddenly everything is audible. Rule: edit on a tone as close as possible to the final one.

The fix: learn it and record it

The engineer eventually got fed up, picked up the guitar and recorded the riff himself ⁠—⁠ with natural transitions between notes. Instead of hours of editing, loop the section, learn it, and then record it.

FAQ

Can editing fix a badly recorded guitar?
No. No mix or master will hide an out-of-tune string, copied attacks or extreme stretching.

What tone should I edit guitars on?
One as close as possible to the final sound ⁠—⁠ high gain masks artifacts that show up on a cleaner tone.

Tools in this episode

  • Reaper (DAW)

Work on your music

Explore mixing services

View the course (in Polish)