A PLN 600 Microphone vs a PLN 15,000 One: Can You Hear the Difference?
A blind test of a cheap U87 clone and an original Neumann — solo, in the mix and after EQ matching.
Does a more expensive microphone always sound better? In this episode Wojtek Wieslawski compares two microphones with a colossal price gap — dozens of times. For most of the video he doesn’t reveal which is which, so you can judge the sound alone. It isn’t sponsored: one of the mics was left with him for a few weeks of testing by a course participant.
The test setup
A blind test: first acoustic guitar, then vocals, labelled A and B. Preamp settings and gain are identical, and it’s even the same take. The song was recorded by the band sleep.city during a studio visit.
Solo, the brighter one wins
When Wojtek ran this test on his in-person course, most participants picked mic A straight away. No surprise: solo it sounds much brighter and more colourful, and our ears naturally read a brighter sound as more attractive.
In the mix, it flips
After compression, with vocal and acoustic together in the mix, Wojtek’s impression is the opposite. With identical compression settings, sibilance from mic A starts to jump out and you’d need a de-esser right away. Mic B sounds slightly muddy solo, yet in the context of the mix it holds up much better — more natural and warmer.
Which is which?
Mic A is a Chinese “donor” — a budget U87 copy at around PLN 600 (if you can even find one). Mic B is an original vintage Neumann U87 costing well over ten thousand złoty.
The twist: EQ matching
Finally, Wojtek matched the cheap mic’s tone to the Neumann with sonible smart:EQ — separately for vocals and acoustic guitar, with the same compression. Can you still hear a difference after matching? Judge for yourself in the video.
The takeaway
What sounds more attractive solo doesn’t always work better in the mix. Judge a microphone in the context of the song and the processing that follows, not only by first impressions.
FAQ
Does a cheap U87 clone sound like the original?
Solo it may even seem more appealing because it’s brighter. In the mix after compression, the original held up better in this test.
Can EQ make a cheap mic sound like an expensive one?
You can get the response closer, for example with a matching EQ. Whether the difference disappears is worth testing on your own material.
Tools in this episode
- Neumann U87 (vintage)
- Budżetowa chińska kopia U87
- sonible smart:EQ 4
Work on your music
Music courtesy of: sleep.city.