I Replaced the Snare on St. Anger — Drum Replacement Step by Step
Stem separation, MIDI and blending two snares — what St. Anger could sound like with a different snare.
Chapters
In the early 2000s the snare on Metallica’s “St. Anger” was the number one topic among engineers and musicians. Out of pure curiosity — without criticising the band — Wojtek Wieslawski checks how “Frantic” would sound with a different snare. Along the way he shows a technique of blending parts of two snares that few people think of.
What bothers us in the original
It’s the distinctive Ludwig Black Beauty sound — the popular story is that it happened by accident when the snares were left off during the session. The controversial part is mostly the tail: without snares it rings long and loud.
The replacement method
- Download the multitracks — stereo drums, bass, guitars and vocals.
- Run the drum track through the free MVSEP service to separate kick, snare, cymbals and toms.
- In Cubase, detect kick and snare hits with hitpoints and convert them to MIDI.
- Use that MIDI to trigger any virtual drum kit — here two snares from the Hertz Drums libraries.
Snare blending: attack from one, tail from the other
Every sample consists of close mics (top, bottom, FX — what Wojtek calls the “attack”) and distant ones (rooms, reverbs, overheads — the “tail”). From the first snare he used only the close mics: dry, in-your-face, no tail. From the second, only the distant ones, which provide the space. Both are triggered by the same hit.
Tuning to the key
The song is in D, so the close mics are tuned to A, a fifth above. The tail stays lower, around D — so it supports the snare, makes it bigger and doesn’t get annoying. Wojtek checks the samples’ pitch with a prototype of a new plugin.
Kick and the drum bus
The kick is also split into close and distant mics: a little less low end around 120 Hz and a low cut on the close mics; compression and a strong cut of about 7 dB around 120 Hz on the distant ones. On the drum bus, just a clipper for extra punch. Separate mics also make room automation possible: more or less room on different riffs, and in the breakdown the original, higher-tuned tails come back.
How did a record like this get released?
From his own months-long sessions, Wojtek knows how easy it is to lose perspective when you hear the same recordings every day — and how hard it is to say “no” to a drummer who wants exactly that snare.
FAQ
How do I create MIDI from recorded drums?
Separate the drums into stems (e.g. with MVSEP), detect the hits with hitpoints in your DAW and convert them to MIDI.
What is snare blending?
Combining two snare samples — for example the close-mic attack of one with the room tail of another.
Tools in this episode
- Cubase (hitpoints → MIDI)
- MVSEP (darmowa separacja stemów)
- Hertz Drums Grand Rock
- Hertz Drums Fame & Fury